For being such a well-known place and such an old city (by American standards), St. Louis is actually a relatively small city. St. Louis is home to Anheuser-Busch of Budweiser fame; it hosted, in the same year, a World’s Fair and an Olympic Games (1904 – the first Olympics in the United States); the Cardinals are a storied baseball team. Most of us are familiar with Charles Lindbergh’s Spirit of St. Louis and the film Meet Me in St. Louis. St. Louis has most of the things that seem to characterize a cosmopolitan city: museums, trendy restaurants, nightlife, a large urban park, a symphony orchestra, a passable light rail system, an international airport, a well regarded research university, three major sports teams, and at least one iconic feature: the Gateway Arch. Yet as I drove around town on a recent visit, seeing various neighborhoods, and trying to figure out what made this place special, it was hard to escape the feeling that there wasn’t much going on. It felt like a smaller version of a city like Chicago, or even San Diego. It was sort of a Portland of the Midwest, though less hipsterific. But it’s hard to distinguish yourself by being a smaller version of something else. As Emerson wrote in the Divinity School Address,
Imitation cannot go above its model. The imitator dooms himself to hopeless mediocrity. The inventor did it, because it was natural to him, and so in him it has a charm. In the imitator, something else is natural, and he bereaves himself of his own beauty, to come short of another man’s.
* * *
Rue Lafayette, a café cum antiques and vintage goods store. Note the A. E. Housman poem, “With Rue My Heart is Laden,” framed. Is there a pun there?
* * *
St. Louis compares favorably with another medium-sized Midwestern city I’ve visited: Cleveland. That probably doesn’t sound like a recommendation, but both of these cities have beauty to find, and I’ve enjoyed my chances to visit less obviously enchanting places. When you go to New York, if you’re a certain sort of savvy traveler, you try to look for “off the beaten path” attractions and “neighborhood joints,” and you marvel at your good luck and ingenuity when you capture a taste of what the “locals” do, as opposed to getting mired in tourist traps. But when you visit a place like St. Louis, it’s pretty much all “off the beaten path,” and it allows you to appreciate discovering a place without the mist of preconception between you and it.
My only regret upon leaving the Gateway City was that I didn’t try the St. Louis-style pizza, which is distinguished by the thin and crispy crust and the trademarked Provel cheese, a kind of processed cheese that I have heard will “stick to your mouth” and is “kind of gross.” Apparently, this oddity can only be found in St. Louis and the environs, and the locals seem to either love it or hate it. Maybe some even love to hate it, which is as strong a recommendation as I can think of for trying it.
Next time, St. Lou. Next time . . .